Sprouting and beyond
How to Grow Potatoes in Water
A potato will sprout in plain water, but it won't produce a crop. In water, a potato lives on its own stored energy to make shoots and roots. To grow new potatoes, the plant also needs nutrients, light and a dark place for tubers to form. A Kratky container provides all three.
Sprouting a potato in a jar of water
This is the classic kitchen project, and a good way to watch roots form.
- Pick a firm potato with visible eyes. Seed potatoes and organic potatoes sprout most reliably, because some supermarket potatoes are treated to stop sprouting.
- Push three or four toothpicks into the middle of the potato and rest them on the rim of a jar, so that the bottom third of the potato sits in water.
- Put the jar somewhere bright but out of hot direct sun.
- Change the water every few days, or sooner if it turns cloudy or smells.
- Roots and shoots usually appear within one to two weeks.
A jar potato makes a good project for children and classrooms, because the roots are easy to watch through the glass. Remind young growers that the sprouts aren't food: potato sprouts can be toxic and shouldn't be eaten.
Why some potatoes won't sprout
If nothing happens after two or three weeks, the potato may have been treated with a sprout inhibitor. Many potatoes sold for eating are treated this way so that they keep longer in the store and the pantry. A treated potato may sprout weakly or not at all. Very fresh potatoes can also be slow, because a newly harvested tuber has a natural rest period before its eyes start to grow. Certified seed potatoes avoid both problems. If you'd still like to try, see growing potatoes from store-bought potatoes, and for the kitchen experiment with peels, can you grow potatoes from peels?
What plain water can't do
Once the potato has used up its stored starch, growth stalls. Plain water has no nitrogen, potassium or other nutrients, so the leaves turn yellow and no new tubers form. The part of the potato under water also tends to rot after a few weeks.
Jar of water vs Kratky container
- What the roots drink: plain water in a jar; complete hydroponic nutrient solution in a Kratky container.
- Container: a clear jar lets light in; a Kratky container is opaque, so tubers and roots stay dark and algae can't grow.
- Where the potato sits: partly under water in a jar; above the solution in a basket of perlite or coco coir in a Kratky container.
- Upkeep: fresh water every few days in a jar; one fill and small top-ups in a Kratky container.
- Result: roots, shoots and a few leaves in a jar; new potatoes in a Kratky container.
Moving from water to the Kratky method
When the sprouts are a few inches long, you can move the potato into a Kratky container: a deep, opaque container of hydroponic nutrient solution with a net pot or basket in the lid. The potato sits in perlite or coco coir above the solution rather than in it, and new tubers form in that dark medium. As the plant drinks, the solution level falls and leaves an air gap that gives the upper roots oxygen.
To make the move:
- Mix the nutrient solution to the label's strength, check the pH, and fill the container so the solution just reaches the base of the basket.
- Put a layer of damp medium in the basket.
- Take the potato off its toothpicks and set it on the medium with the shoots pointing up. Let the roots trail down through the basket toward the solution.
- Fill around and over the potato with more medium, leaving the shoots in the light.
- Close any gaps around the basket so no light reaches the solution.
Work quickly so the water roots don't dry out, and handle them gently. Roots that grew in water may take a little time to adjust to the medium, so don't worry if the plant pauses for a few days. From here, follow how to grow potatoes without soil for topping up, adding medium and harvesting.
Questions about growing potatoes in water
Can you grow a whole potato plant in just water?
Not to harvest. Plain water supports sprouting and early root growth only. For tubers, the plant needs nutrient solution and a dark root zone.
Do potatoes grown in water need nutrients?
Yes, once they move past the sprouting stage. A complete hydroponic nutrient supplies what soil would.
How often should I change the water?
In a sprouting jar, every few days. In a Kratky container you don't change it: you let the level fall and top up only a little when needed.
Can I plant a water-sprouted potato in soil?
Yes. Once the roots are a few inches long, plant it with the sprouts just below the surface and handle the roots gently.
Why is my potato rotting in the water?
Usually too much of it is under water, the water is stale, or it's too warm. Keep only the bottom third in water and change it more often.
Can I eat potatoes grown this way?
Tubers grown in a Kratky container are eaten like any other potato. Don't eat green parts, and don't eat the old seed potato after it has sprouted.
Related Kratky potato guides
More on growing potatoes with the Kratky method, from the first sprout to the harvest.